Central athlete clearly preserves the assigned Noun number, silhouette, pixel construction, noggles, and reference-art character before state styling.
Reject if: The result looks like a generic mascot, human athlete, stock cartoon, or unrelated state character.AGENCY 50 / CREATIVE DIRECTOR REVIEW
Approve the actual Nouns before the campaign goes public.
Pick a state poster, score the five professional lanes, paste a generated-image reference, and copy an accept, remix, or reject receipt. The bar is simple: preserve the assigned actual Noun first, then make the state campaign feel undeniable.
Scorecard
Creative Director Desk
Five-lane review
Score the artifact
A viewer can identify the state from one strong local motif without relying only on text.
Reject if: The poster uses vague Americana, generic sports fields, or scenery disconnected from the assigned state.The poster feels like part of “Fifty States. Fifty Nouns. One Union Night.” with type hierarchy, safe zones, and repeatable lockup logic.
Reject if: The composition is beautiful but cannot sit next to the other 49 posters as a unified campaign.Works as a poster, mobile story, and TV pregame still with readable team name, state code, and Nouns Union tag.
Reject if: Key type is too small, clipped, illegible, or too busy for mobile/TV use.No official sports marks, school marks, betting language, checkout language, official relationship claim, or promised financial return.
Reject if: Any real league/team/school mark, odds/picks framing, or payout implication appears.Professional standards
What must be true before anything ships.
State code, team name, and assigned actual Noun number.
Prompt used and model lane.
Generated image URL or local file reference.
Reviewer note describing what passed or what must change.
Human decision: accept, remix, or reject.
Route to poster wall, State Night broadcast stills, sponsor-safe inventory, or participant-credit queue after human approval.
Return to image model or creative agent with the weakest review lane and one concrete fix.
Archive the receipt with rejection reason; do not publish, sell, route, or credit the artifact.
